Expertise / Medical & Clinical Negligence / Orthopaedic

Orthopaedic expert witnesses

Consultant orthopaedic surgeons for clinical negligence, personal injury and insurance claims.

Request an expert

Orthopaedic evidence is needed in more claims than almost any other medical specialty: missed fractures, delayed tendon and nerve repairs, joint replacements that fail, and injuries whose long-term effects have to be separated from wear and tear that was already there. We introduce consultant orthopaedic surgeons, chosen by sub-specialty, who report regularly for the courts.

This is one of the specialisms within our medical expert witness practice.

In medical & clinical negligence, the difference between a strong case and a weak one often comes down to whether the expert truly understands the sector. Generalist opinion rarely survives scrutiny on specialist questions, and a tribunal gives little weight to evidence that misreads how medical & clinical negligence actually works. We focus here precisely because the issues are technical, the stakes are high, and the wrong expert is an expensive mistake.

What instructing through us looks like

Tell us the issues, the forum and your timeline. We check fit, availability and conflicts, then send a short, honest shortlist. You review CVs and speak with the expert before instructing. New to the process? See our guide on how to instruct an expert witness.

Enquire

Tell us about your orthopaedic matter

Describe the issues and the forum. We check fit, availability and conflicts, then come back with a short shortlist. Enquiries are confidential and create no obligation.

What happens next

  1. Tell us the matterShare the issues, the sector and your timeline. No obligation, treated in confidence.
  2. We shortlistWe identify experts whose experience genuinely fits, and check availability and conflicts.
  3. You instructYou review CVs and speak directly with the expert before instructing on your terms.

What orthopaedic claims turn on

In clinical negligence, the orthopaedic expert answers two separate questions. Breach of duty: was the care supported by a responsible body of orthopaedic opinion at the time, in line with Bolam and Bolitho, and was the patient told about the material risks of treatment as Montgomery requires? Causation: on the balance of probabilities, what would have happened with proper care, and what difference does that make to the claimant now? The two questions often need the same surgeon to keep them carefully apart, because a delay can be negligent and still have made no difference to the outcome.

In personal injury, the question is usually condition and prognosis: what injury the accident caused, how the claimant has recovered, and what the future holds. Where the claimant already had degenerative changes, as many adults do in the neck, back and knees, the expert has to say whether the accident caused new damage or brought forward symptoms that would have come anyway, and if so by how long. That 'acceleration' period often decides the value of the claim.

Claims we see most often

  • Missed and delayed fractures: scaphoid, hip, cervical spine and paediatric fractures missed in the emergency department or on first X-ray.
  • Tendon and soft tissue injuries: Achilles ruptures managed inconsistently or repaired late, and missed tendon injuries in the hand.
  • Spinal emergencies: delayed diagnosis of cauda equina syndrome or spinal cord compression, where hours can matter.
  • Joint replacement: malpositioned implants, infection, dislocation, metal-on-metal hips and revision surgery.
  • Complications of surgery: nerve and vessel injury, compartment syndrome, wrong-site surgery and consent.
  • Accident injuries: fractures, ligament and meniscal tears, and spinal injuries after road traffic, workplace and sporting accidents.

Choosing the right orthopaedic surgeon

Orthopaedics is divided into sub-specialties, and courts give more weight to an expert who treats the condition in question every week. A claim about an ankle fracture belongs with a foot and ankle surgeon; a failed hip replacement with a hip surgeon; a missed scaphoid fracture with a hand and wrist surgeon. For breach of duty, the expert should also have practised at the relevant level at the time: the standard expected of a junior doctor in an emergency department is not the standard expected of a consultant.

Some claims also need a second discipline. Emergency medicine experts address what should have happened in the emergency department; radiologists address what an X-ray or scan showed; and a pain specialist or psychiatrist may address chronic pain and its effects. We can introduce those experts alongside the orthopaedic surgeon so the reports fit together.

Questions an orthopaedic expert is asked

  • Was the injury recognised and investigated as it should have been at each stage?
  • Was the chosen treatment, operative or non-operative, one a responsible body of surgeons would have chosen?
  • Would earlier treatment have produced a better result, and how much better?
  • How much of the claimant's current disability is due to the accident or the negligence, and how much to pre-existing conditions?
  • Can the claimant return to their job, or to sport, and what is the risk of future arthritis or surgery?

FAQ

Common questions

What does an orthopaedic expert witness do?

They give independent, objective opinion to a court or tribunal on orthopaedic issues within medical & clinical negligence, with an overriding duty to the court under CPR Part 35. The opinion usually takes the form of a written report and, where required, oral evidence.

When should I instruct an orthopaedic expert?

As soon as the issues are clear. Early instruction helps you test the strengths and weaknesses of the case, scope the evidence proportionately and avoid a rushed report against a deadline.

How do you select experts for orthopaedic matters?

On substance: relevant qualifications, genuine medical & clinical negligence experience and an understanding of an expert's duties in litigation and arbitration. Where an expert has limited experience of giving evidence, we say so.

Do you have orthopaedic surgeons who report on sports injuries?

Yes. Several of the consultants we work with treat sports injuries in their clinical practice, including foot and ankle and knee surgeons, and report on return to play as well as on the injury itself.

Can an orthopaedic expert examine the claimant?

Yes. Most condition and prognosis reports follow an examination at the expert's clinic; breach of duty reports in clinical negligence are often based on the medical records alone. Tell us which you need and we'll confirm the expert's arrangements and turnaround.

Need an orthopaedic expert?

Describe the matter and we'll identify specialists who fit.

Request an expert

More Medical & Clinical Negligence specialisms